Experiments in spring/shock tuning for looks, comfort, and handling
Posted: 31 Aug 2017, 00:28
The primary design philosophy/goal for my white '91 is maintaining a "stockish +" look and/or feel. Sort of like if Honda had made a "Type-S" version of the 3g, a little more sporty than the SI but not as hard as a "Type-R" version would be. It should remain comfortable, relatively quiet, have full accessories (ice cold A/C especially), and a layman should have a hard time identifying it as modified, if at all.
This post will show what I'm working on suspension wise to meet that goal, in case you want to share ideas or try something similar.
I first ruled out a full coil-over setup like KSports due to the fact that they offer a much too stiff ride for what I'm wanting to do, as well as being very obvious visually. I was left with going the traditional route of new shocks/dampers and springs.
Tokico HP shocks (better known as Tokico "blues") used to be the default choice and are an excellent option if you can find them. But they have been hard to get a hold of in recent years (were even rumored to be discontinued for a while). They also happen to be painted bright blue, which goes against my "stockish +" goal. After a little searching I found that Sachs makes 3g shocks and the brand seems to have a decent reputation, plus they are painted black and look very similar to the stock shocks:

For spring selection I wanted a moderate amount of lowering while keeping a low spring rate for the best ride quality and grip. I had several sets of stock springs hanging around my garage so I opted to cut some coils off a set. I took 2.25 coils off the front springs and 1.75 off the rear. Cutting coils off a spring increases its rate, so first we will look at the specs of the stock springs measured off my car:
Here are the specs after cutting:
That is a 28% increase in rate for the front and 25% for the rear. I cut more off the front primarily so that there would be slightly less wheel gap in the front than rear, giving the car some rake. (This was mostly a stylistic choice.) Here is an example of the lowering/wheel gap after the cutting:


When I assembled the shocks and springs I left the dust shields off and used stock bump stops. After installing and setting the car on the ground I checked the shocks to see how much travel they would have before hitting the bump stops. I was somewhat surprised to see that they were already sitting on the stops in the front and looked to have .25" - .5" of travel in the rear. I cut the stock bump stops in half and that gave me acceptable travel in the rear but the front still only had about .25" worth of travel. This means I would be hitting the stops quite often. The car isn't even that low either, which means most people running sport or especially race springs are probably riding on their front bump stops all the time, even if they are cut. There simply isn't enough travel available in then front due to the low hood line.
The easiest solution at this point was to modify the stock top hats into raised ones, to give me more shock travel. I was able to raise them enough to give me approximately 2" more travel in the front and 3" in the rear. Here is what they look like:



The red top bushings were only temporary until some black ones came in.
At this point I had decent travel before I would hit the cut-in-half bump stops. But since I'm going for a "stock +" setup I wanted a way to ride on just the springs for cruising and minor dips/bumps, but then quickly ramp up the spring rate as the suspension started to compress. (This would give me a good ride quality while still controlling body roll and potential to bottom out) To achieve this I switched to progressive bump stops:

Unlike the stock bump stops which shoot the spring rate up suddenly these are much more gradual, you want them to intentionally make contact at some point. It would be better to think of them as secondary springs that add rate to the coil springs as they are compressed. Here is a graph showing the amount of increase as they are compressed:

I had to cut the big end off the fronts so they would fit up into the raised top hat, right now they have like 1/8" travel before they start to compress and add spring rate to the front springs. In the rear I didn't need to cut them and they have ~1/2" travel before starting to compress. The ride quality is very good until I start hitting big dips of bumps. I've ordered a new set of COT Red bump stops for the front, which are softer than the blue ones. I think with those installed in the front the car should handle the big bumps better but still not have any problems with bottoming out.
That about covers where I am with tuning the spring/shock assembly, I will update after installing and testing the softer front stops.
This post will show what I'm working on suspension wise to meet that goal, in case you want to share ideas or try something similar.
I first ruled out a full coil-over setup like KSports due to the fact that they offer a much too stiff ride for what I'm wanting to do, as well as being very obvious visually. I was left with going the traditional route of new shocks/dampers and springs.
Tokico HP shocks (better known as Tokico "blues") used to be the default choice and are an excellent option if you can find them. But they have been hard to get a hold of in recent years (were even rumored to be discontinued for a while). They also happen to be painted bright blue, which goes against my "stockish +" goal. After a little searching I found that Sachs makes 3g shocks and the brand seems to have a decent reputation, plus they are painted black and look very similar to the stock shocks:

For spring selection I wanted a moderate amount of lowering while keeping a low spring rate for the best ride quality and grip. I had several sets of stock springs hanging around my garage so I opted to cut some coils off a set. I took 2.25 coils off the front springs and 1.75 off the rear. Cutting coils off a spring increases its rate, so first we will look at the specs of the stock springs measured off my car:
Code: Select all
FRONT REAR
Coil diameter: .49" Coil diameter: .425"
Inside diameter: 2.375" Inside diameter: 2.75"
Coil mean diameter: 2.875" Coil mean diameter: 3.175"
Active coils: ~10.25 Active coils: ~8.75
Spring rate: 333 lb/in Spring rate: 164 lb/in
Code: Select all
FRONT REAR
" "
Active coils: ~8 Active coils: ~7
Spring rate: 427 lb/in Spring rate: 205 lb/in


When I assembled the shocks and springs I left the dust shields off and used stock bump stops. After installing and setting the car on the ground I checked the shocks to see how much travel they would have before hitting the bump stops. I was somewhat surprised to see that they were already sitting on the stops in the front and looked to have .25" - .5" of travel in the rear. I cut the stock bump stops in half and that gave me acceptable travel in the rear but the front still only had about .25" worth of travel. This means I would be hitting the stops quite often. The car isn't even that low either, which means most people running sport or especially race springs are probably riding on their front bump stops all the time, even if they are cut. There simply isn't enough travel available in then front due to the low hood line.
The easiest solution at this point was to modify the stock top hats into raised ones, to give me more shock travel. I was able to raise them enough to give me approximately 2" more travel in the front and 3" in the rear. Here is what they look like:



The red top bushings were only temporary until some black ones came in.
At this point I had decent travel before I would hit the cut-in-half bump stops. But since I'm going for a "stock +" setup I wanted a way to ride on just the springs for cruising and minor dips/bumps, but then quickly ramp up the spring rate as the suspension started to compress. (This would give me a good ride quality while still controlling body roll and potential to bottom out) To achieve this I switched to progressive bump stops:

Unlike the stock bump stops which shoot the spring rate up suddenly these are much more gradual, you want them to intentionally make contact at some point. It would be better to think of them as secondary springs that add rate to the coil springs as they are compressed. Here is a graph showing the amount of increase as they are compressed:

I had to cut the big end off the fronts so they would fit up into the raised top hat, right now they have like 1/8" travel before they start to compress and add spring rate to the front springs. In the rear I didn't need to cut them and they have ~1/2" travel before starting to compress. The ride quality is very good until I start hitting big dips of bumps. I've ordered a new set of COT Red bump stops for the front, which are softer than the blue ones. I think with those installed in the front the car should handle the big bumps better but still not have any problems with bottoming out.
That about covers where I am with tuning the spring/shock assembly, I will update after installing and testing the softer front stops.